
By Joseph Trento, DCBureau.org
The Kurds call themselves the other Iraq. They even have an advertising campaign:
Have you seen the Other Iraq?
It’s spectacular.
It’s peaceful.
It’s joyful.
Fewer than two hundred US troops are stationed here.
Arabs, Kurds and Westerners all vacation together.
What this Kurdish PR campaign omits is that the hospitable Kurds hire the U.S. generals and diplomats who helped them – the former U.S. government officials who made the other Iraq possible.
I bet you didn’t know there is another other Kurdish Iraq. It’s based in Washington, D.C., in a beautiful, revamped multi-million dollar building. It uses a plagiarist as its spokesperson. It hires former military generals who commanded U.S. troops and rewards former diplomats with oil deals. It maintains several homes in the Washington area and runs up Newt-Gingrich-sized jewelry store accounts. It gives away $25,000 watches for gifts.
The equivalent of Mario Puzo’s The Godfather is playing out in the Kurdish region of Iraq. Its two main political families grow wealthier by the day on the oil riches. They build huge mansions back home with large staffs and private jets. They own radio and television stations and control the media. The Talabani and Barzani families have made a temporary peace as they divide up the riches of power and use former American generals and diplomats to tend to the details of keeping Washington happy enough so the Kurdish gravy train does not run off the tracks. That makes our generals and diplomats working for these two political gangs the equivalent of the corrupt New York police official who Michael Corleone dispatches in the novel.
The two main Kurdish political parties have friendly former U.S. general officers, starting with Jake Garner, on their payroll to do their bidding in Washington. They are the best ex-generals (and a few diplomats) that money can buy.
The generals who sent our young soldiers to war in Iraq are cashing in by serving the interests of families who are fundamentally refusing to share Iraq’s oil wealth which is leading to more conflict and death. It is a mindlessly corrupt former U.S. general officer corps that will do anything for cash and a business class ticket.
And now there is trouble back home. The wealth is not being shared beyond these two political families. The gleaming new business hubs of Kurdistan offer little to those who are not members of the clans. The people who are not affiliated with either clan are protesting the mansions and brazen corruption that is the new Kurdistan, increasingly with violence.
When things get out of hand, the Kurdish leaders call in the vaunted peshmergas to take care of the troublemakers. Protests, after all, are bad for business, and business is booming in Kurdistan.
There is no democracy, only corruption. One Kurdish candidate says, “Money is everything on the ground. They buy votes. It’s the only reason they are in power. …No banks. Envelopes. If you are not with the Kurdish party, you have nothing. There are no government books. No accounting. It’s a cash society.”
Most average Kurds do not get to live in huge mansions or stay in luxury hotels made possible by American blood and tax money and our pliable former military officers and fast buck ex-diplomats.
Iraqi President Talabani’s slipping of cash to wounded warriors during visits at Walter Reed is an image of a man who had the most to profit from U.S. intervention handing out tips to American soldiers who sacrificed body parts to make his oil empire possible.
We at the National Security News Service helped unearth the scandal that became David Barstow’s Pentagon consultants’ story a few years ago. We know a great deal about American general officers who peddle their reputations to sell wars and military hardware. These guys are nothing more than mercenaries who wrap themselves in the flag and get wealthy on the backs of the men and woman they once commanded.
The photographs of our very best generals and diplomats rushing to the Kurdish faction to cash in make this tawdry tail even uglier. General officers get a decent pension. They get medical care and PX privileges.
How much money is enough? When does going on the payroll of Kurdish political bosses or others profiting from the wars become conduct unbecoming?
Joseph Trento has spent more than 35 years as an investigative journalist, working with both print and broadcast outlets and writing extensively. Before joining the National Security News Service in 1991, Trento worked for CNN’s Special Assignment Unit, the Wilmington News Journal, and prominent journalist Jack Anderson. Trento has received six Pulitzer nominations and is the author of five books, including Prelude to Terror, The Secret History of the CIA, Widows, and Prescription for Disaster. Joe currently serves as the editor of DCBureau.org.



This article lets me have the impression that the writer is very very angry.
So the question is: what is he angry from?
Is he upset that some of his fellow american generals are making money out of their past career?
If it is that then its an american western problem, not a kurdish one. This is a completely common practice in the west that former politicians and other high ranking people move into the business domain and often get rich.
The former german chancellor Gerhard Schröder sits on the advisory board of a subsidiary company of the russian Gazprom. His former foreign minister Joshka Fischer is an advisor for Gazprom to drag off the german RWE from the Nabuco gas pipeline to Europe and they make a fortune out of it.
There are countless examples of this sort. So it is your western capitalistic system that has a moral problem.
I was disappointed from those generals as well as I heard that they are being payed for their advise and help.
I was expecting them to help out of passion believing that it would be noble to help a people like Kurds who have suffered so much devestation for centuries and still do.
But if you are criticising the kurdish KRG for their corruption and other problems then you have to be fair and tell the other side of the story.
You can’t judge and gage the KRG by the same standards as in the west or as in countries that have been independent and had their sovereignty for a long time.
We Kurds are just coming back from the deads. We certainly need decades and decades of development to raech a decent level of a working and just society.
Those shortcomings in Kurdistan are no surprise. Other much more sophisticated countries have the same or even bigger problems just look at the wealthy arab countries, Russia, South Africa and many many other places in the world.
If you are a true journalist who cares about right and wrong then you should not hide what is the core isssue which is the right of the kurdish people to live freely and be safe of the killings and destruction done to us by Iraq, Iran, Turkey and Syria.
Surrounded by so much hatred and attacks by those countries for many centuries, it is no suprise that you would find a lot of disfunctionalities in Kurdistan which take a lot of time to improve and come near any western standards.
By the way you are emphasizing on the sacrifices of the american army and distort the facts by creating the impression as if they came to do Talabani a favour.
Even the most naiive person knows that they came out of their own american interests and it is wrong what many american journalists and activists tell that the US are supporting the KRG of Talabani and Barzani.
The truth is the US has misused their status as “so called” friends of the kurds by blackmailing the KRG to back down every time when it comes to a dispute with the arab majority in Bagdad.
The last blackmail was that from Obama who did personally phone Barzani and forced him to accept an iraqi election law which disfranchised thousends of kurdish votes and forced him to accept the fabricated high numbers of arab voters in Mosul aand Diyala which was a big blow to the kurdish representation in the iraqi parlament.
You do have a lot of reasons to criticise your country and its system but please do that with your own US issues and not on our backs.
And if you honour us with your analysis please keep the dimensions right and don’t treat us as if we have been a free and prosperous nation for centries as you are.
You wouldn’t blame someone who is just coming out of a horrific car accident and say:
“go away.. your face is full of blood and dirt and your clothes are filthy”.
Sincerely
Dilshad Xoshnaw
Mr Trento’s article is trenchant but that does not mean that he is ‘very angry’.
And who can honestly dispute this observation about the KRG?
“The wealth is not being shared beyond these two political families. The gleaming new business hubs of Kurdistan offer little to those who are not members of the clans”.
Because we have suffered for so long in the past, must we (who are not ‘on the payroll’) now accept exploitation and repression by ‘our own’ rulers?
It is indeed disgusting what is happening in this KRG administration.. no one can deny that. The point is what would you do about it.
If you want to have a solution then you have to understand the reason for those problems and know how they historically developed otherwise you would cure the wrong disease.
Those who believe that the problem is a bunch of corrupt PDK/PUK officals at the top and you just have to replace them then everything is done.. those are completetly wrong.
Apart of the fact that the causes are rooted in a much wider social and cultural disfunctionality you can’t make the PDK/PUK just disappear.
The current bad and shaky balance is the result of lengthy and painful fights between PDK and PUK and others.
Throwing them away is impossible and would create a vacuum which Iran, Turkey and Iraq would be happy to fill.
In my view a bad administration is far better than going back to times as others (Baathists/Arabs) ruled kurdistan.
Gorran and the Islamists are no replacement for the PDK/PUK because they share the same past and the same sins.
So if you really want an improvement without risking to lose all what is achieved then you have to try to reform the system gradually specially because it is widely a cultural issue before it is a PdK/PUK issue.
You have to change the kind of mentality among the kurdish society that makes such corruption and incompetence possible.
The mentallity and the moral of the majority of the kurdish people is the basis for such a corrupt system at the top.
As long as this is unchanged there will always be corrupt people in command.
By creating chaos and turmoil in Kurdistan, occupying the centers of the cities in PUK-Kurdistan you would destroy even that little and shaky rule the Kurds currently have.
During the civil war in the 199x PDK and PUK proved that are not ready to give up their position even if they had to go to war and lose so many of their peshmargas…
back then “only” millions were involved.. now it is about billions, so they would be prepared to sacrifice even more.
You can’t command from the top that corruption should stop immediately. It must be the vast majority of the Kurds who reject corruption in their daily lives completely. Only then we have a real chance to improve.
Just name 10 individuals in Kurdistan who took over an important position and they were not corrupted later on!
I know of people who refused to participate in the corruption but were even laughed at by their own friends and relatives that they were “foolish” and didn’t know how to “eat”.
This is kurdistan.
No one from the top of PDK/PUK forces you to be corrupt but the vast majority of the people don’t hesitate to be part of it.
It’s time that honest Kurds point also to themselves and don’t put the whole blame on the KRG and others.
Very well written article. fair, balanced, and unbiased. I congratulate the writer as he’s spoken the hearts and minds of most of the free-loving Kurds of the region. Moreover, the writer addressed a growing problem in the region alas no menition of the recent uprising in the region. It is obvious that these former generals are not really helping push forward the Kurdish question in the White House, but they are only helping in strengthening these two totalitarian families against present and future demonstrations and uprisings in Kurdistan. It is to be expected that those who are materially connected to the corrupt tribal regime in Kurdistan would not welcome this article.
I am sorry but by reading such comments I am forced to think at Pavlov’s dogs and their reflexes.
It seems that you read something that you don’t like and your reflexes are “this is a person who is materially connected to the KRG” etc.
This is a generalization and a baseless accusation.
You don’t know me and have no proof for your accusation, but you know the thoughts I have expressed here.
If you have something to object so please make your objection clear to what you don’t agree with.
But by accusing others of something without proof and without reasoning makes you look like someone who has nothing to say.
Mr Dilshad, as a free European citizen, I merely commented on the article of this gentleman. If you look at the background solid colour of my comment, you would see it is white; which means it is unconnected to your comment. This comment, however, is a response to your reply to my earlier comment and the background colour should now be the same as your reply. Albeit I respect your opinion, I couldn’t see any relation between my earlier comment and “conditioning”! 😀 We have a saying in Sulaimani: relating “conditioning” to my comment is like comparing god with a pair of socks! 😉
A NEW BOOK TO BE PUBLISHED SOON ” ENTITLED” : !
POST-SADDAM IRAQ, CIA AND KURDISH LEADERS